Hi, Skunkworks--
Yeah, water-based is essentially more logical for both
ALC and MSM given their solubility profiles. I just wanted an ointment that made my poor skin feel better, and also allowed for a mild sort of massage. And
DMSO would
probably be better still. I don't fear anything about
DMSO. It just doesn't make my skin feel all that good, and doesn't seem to have any positive effect in and of itself. I've had excellent results in pain relief and healing from
DMSO elsewhere on my body. At the moment, however, my penis isn't a big fan!
Incidentally, one of the weird aspects of
DMSO is that it generally enhances absorption of both polar and non-polar molecules
So, I'm not actually doing what the chemistry would suggest as a first option. I'm doing what seems to make some sense while also making me feel more comfortable.
That said, I'm fascinated to see what results people might get with other approaches. So, rock on!
Melting,
I think you're right about Thackers.
Although everybody treats
DMSO as something verging on magic, and molecular weight as if it is predictive, from what little I can tell it's all more complicated than that, and every substance would need to be studied individually and in pairs (i.e. Substance A + Solvent B).
DMSO doesn't treat all comers equally, and neither does skin.
People tend to use molecular weight as a proxy for absorbability, with a cutoff of around MW 500 or so. But it actually depends on the shape of the molecule, and its charge, and how lipophilic/lipophobic the molecule is, and who knows what else. So Ubiquinol is on the high side.
ALC is probably fine--and other froms of Carnitine seem to absorb fairly well. In addition, there are things that absorb into the outer layers of skin, but don;t make it all the way through.
Incidentally, one of the weird aspects of
DMSO is that it generally enhances absorption of both polar and non-polar molecules. So if there were anything that would enhance the delivery of both
ALC (polar) and Ubiquinol (relatively nonpolar), it would be
DMSO. But there aren't really good rules of thumb, because it's complicated.
Really big molecules that might be useful locally, like Serrapeptase and Nattokinase, are definitely not absorbable. I notice that some people on this forum have thought they were because they read about special delivery methods--but those involved liposomes or other nanopackage delivery systems. That isn't going to happen with any technology I have access to!
---------------
I don't think there is any problem with mixing water-soluble and non-water soluble components...except that things may not stay in solution. If they are things the skin absorbs naturally, I'm not sure it really matter. If you really wanted to get tricky, you'd find an emulsifier so the water soluble and non-water soluble parts could co-exist. The truth is, though, emulsions are really just suspensions, so it isn't all that different from
ALC in oil. (Mayonnaise is a common example--oil suspended in water, or vice-versa, in a way where it doesn't tend to separate, but isn;t truly 'dissolved' either.)
I think you are right that continuing assault is the thing to do.
I believe that
ALC probably is taken up by the skin if it remains in contact long enough. Probably is sped up by
DMSO. But, if you're already using hot water, I'd guess the best time to go for it is right after hot water exposure and stretching. Both of them make the skin more permeable.
Keep us posted!